Tuesday, July 17, 2012

To trade Castellanos or not? That is the BIG question...

The Tigers are apparently talking trade with a number of teams...the Cubs ( Garza Barney, Dempster), the Diamondbacks (Upton), the Mariners (Vargas), and apparently Greinke from the Brewers...the big question is whether Nick Castellanos is tradeable...I realize that you have to give up something to get something with quality in return....the only guy I would say possibly is Upton who would be worthy and even there I have some reservations...I would not put him in the same category as Cabrera when we traded Cameron Maybin and Andrew Miller along with some other minor leaguers...Upton could be close to Cabrera's caliber in a year or two but then so could Castellanos who is moving to the OF apparently.....What say ye, baseball and Tiger fans...do the Tigers trade him?


  1. No, no, no, NO, NO! Not for any of those guys, never in a million years! He looks like he may make something of himself, and the only player on that list I'd like at all is Upton. Trading for any of the Cubs at all would be a mistake and Vargas and Greinke wouldn't end up being worth it. Toss in the fact that we'd lose our top prospect for someone that wouldn't help much and it adds up to a terrible idea.

  2. Dempster and Barney would kill the holes problem with one stone. Deal Nick, no.
    Cool auto.
    Hope you're well.

  3. Hey do you happen to still have that Mark Reynolds Topps 60 Jumbo Patch you pulled from last year? Please email me at luck15hope@gmail.com if you still happen to have it because I would really like to purchase it from you. Thanks in advance.